top of page
black and white image of mother holding babies hand

BEDTIME BLOGS

Insights from The Pediatric Sleep Nurse

Sleep Training Myths Busted: Safe for Babies, Backed by Science

Let's be real, sleep training is probably one of the most controversial parenting topics out there. Just mention those two words and you're bound to get a flood of opinions - from well-meaning grandparents to sleep-deprived neighbors nodding in solidarity. But amidst all the noise, how much of what we hear about sleep training is actually rooted in facts?


Baby smiling on bed

As a sleep consultant and registered nurse, I've worked with countless families struggling with their little ones' sleep challenges. I was surprised by the amount of misinformation and fear-mongering surrounding sleep training methods. With so many conflicting claims out there, I decided to dive into the research myself. And you know what I found? A lot of the common concerns about sleep training DON’T quite hold up under scientific scrutiny.


Misconception 1: Sleep training causes emotional trauma and attachment issues.


Fear not, parents! Multiple studies, including one from the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, have shown that babies who are sleep trained experience no increase in stress hormones or long-term negative effects on their emotional health or attachment to parents. In fact, improving a baby's sleep can actually enhance their cognitive and emotional development!


Misconception 2: It's cruel to let babies "cry it out."


This one tugs at every parent's heartstrings, but here's the reality - all sleep training methods involve some level of protest from your little one as they learn a new skill. The key is using an age-appropriate approach with assurance and consistency. With gentle strategies like camping out or timed check-ins, you're actually teaching them healthy self-soothing skills. A study in Pediatrics found that babies who were sleep trained using these methods had no lasting adverse effects.


On the flip side, numerous studies, including one from Sleep Medicine Reviews, suggest that helping babies establish good sleep habits and routines can have numerous benefits, including:


• Better sleep quality and duration for both baby and parents (hello, sanity!)

• Improved cognitive development, memory retention, and attention

• Better self-regulation, daily functioning, and positive mood


Of course, every family's situation is unique, and there's no one-size-fits-all approach to sleep. If sleep training isn't working or doesn't align with your parenting philosophy, that's perfectly okay too. Forcing something that causes you chronic stress can counteract any potential benefits.


Myth #3: If you're going to sleep train, you just need a method - no need for a personalized consultant.


While there are many popular sleep training books and programs out there, the reality is that every baby is unique. Their temperaments, sleep needs, and ability to adapt to new routines can vary widely. Sure, you can try to follow a generic sleep training method on your own. But inevitably, questions will arise or issues will pop up that a one-size-fits-all plan can't fully address.


As a certified sleep consultant, I've seen firsthand how complex and nuanced helping a baby learn independent sleep skills can be. There are so many factors at play - is your little one getting enough feedings and wake windows? Are they being inadvertently reinforced for wakeups? How do you navigate regressions or teething? Having an expert who can personally evaluate your situation and provide tailored guidance can make a world of difference.


I always recommend personalized sleep support over just winging it with a book or group class. When hiccups inevitably happen during the training process, it's invaluable to have a professional you can reach out to for customized troubleshooting. With their expertise, you can make adjustments and stay on track - rather than throwing in the towel altogether.


The sleep training journey is challenging enough as it is. Why not give yourself and your baby the best chance at success from the start? A good consultant is worth their weight in peaceful nights.


The main takeaway is - let's ditch the judgment and make decisions based on facts, not fear-mongering. As the "sleep lady" in many households, I've seen firsthand how life-changing consistent, age-appropriate sleep can be for the whole family.


The bottom line is, helping our babies develop healthy sleep habits from an early age can have tremendous benefits for their development and the well-being of the whole family. With some patience and the right approach for your situation, restful nights are absolutely attainable. Who's ready to invest in their little one's optimal start while also reclaiming some much-needed shuteye themselves?



Sources:


Gradisar et al. (2016)


Symon et al. (2012).


Anat Scher. (2005).




Goodlin-Jones et al. (2005).



 

Feeling overwhelmed by all this sleep talk? Need a little extra guidance? Book an Expert Strategy Session with me or sign up for my Premium Support package and get ready to conquer sleep like a pro!


Explore Sleep Support by Age:




thorne the pediatric sleep nurse holdng a baby in overalls

Hi! I'm Thorne

My goal is to make the journey to restful sleep clear, simple, and achievable for every family.

Categories
The pediatric sleep nurse holding a baby in overalls

Hi! I'm Thorne

My goal is to make the journey to restful sleep clear, simple, and achievable for every family.

Categories
bottom of page